Hi all,
I've been thinking about this for a couple of days, as I think I may have been misunderstanding the context of the discussion.
I had thought that basically the exec had put up a white paper, was calling for another arguing a different position, and then we were going to collectively decide what we thought the best route forward was.
Something Alex said the other day, however, makes me wonder if this is actually a confidence question. I.e. the executive have proposed a course of action, asked if there are any alternatives, and intend to resign if their proposal doesn't pass.
That second is a perfectly legitimate thing to do. Executives should not and cannot be asked to execute something they disagree with.
But it changes the calculus for the rest of us--or at least for me. While I think it makes sense to see what would be involved in becoming an ADHO Constituent Organisation before we decide on some other arrangement that precludes that, I don't feel or want to argue that the executive should resign. So if the independence proposal is actually a confidence vote, then I would, at most, abstain. I feel personally that there's an extra step we really could take before pursuing that route; but I don't absolutely require that others agree and I don't think that deciding to do otherwise is a disqualification from leadership.
Moreover, in such cases, if your proposal requires a change in leadership, as this apparently would, then I don't think you should propose something you aren't prepared to lead. I've been chair of GO::DH, and I don't think it would be appropriate to be it again, certainly not this close to having stepped down.
So I suppose if this were the spring and we were voting on candidates for the executive on the basis of platforms that differed along these lines (i.e. independence now vs first looking into what might be involved in being a CO), then I might see that as something that would influence my vote--though it might not even be decisive. But mid-term, where an argument one way is understood as a vote of confidence, I don't really feel comfortable pursuing that argument.
If the question from the executive was "here's a couple of options, help us understand the pros and cons so we can choose a course of action," then I have some thoughts. But if the question is "here's what we want to do, should we do this, or is there some other course that some other people might want to pursue in our places," then I don't really have a proposal. I think the jump to immediate independence is premature and ignores some things that I consider due diligence. But it is by no means irresponsible or beyond the pale, and it isn't something I want to see resignations over!
So I'm not sure I really have anything to add to this discussion. I've been happy with the people on the exec. I wished they agreed with me on investigating joining ADHO as a CO, but it isn't something I want to force a confidence vote on.
-dan
Daniel Paul O'Donnell
Professor of English and Associate Member of the University Library Academic Staff
Editor, Digital Studies/Le champ numérique
Vice President, Force 11
Department of English and University Library
University of Lethbridge
4401 University Drive West
Lethbridge AB T1K 3M4
Canada
Tel. +1 (403) 329-2377
http://people.uleth.ca/~daniel.odonnell
@danielPaulOD
Sent: October 20, 2017 2:31
To: globaloutlookdh-l, MailList
Subject: Re: [globaloutlookDH-l] Why we should leave ADHO, go minimal and return to the planet.
Ernesto and all,
GO::DH membership is defined by subscription to this email list. All members of the list have access to the email addresses of all who have subscribed. You can access it by visiting the following site and logging in: http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/ globaloutlookdh-l
During our last election, we had 545 subscribers, but 25 of those email bounced. It's entirely possible there are individual subscribers who may be subscribed under more than one emails.
Though this information is incomplete, I hope it is of some use.
Roopika
--
On Thu, Oct 19, 2017 at 5:06 PM, Ernesto Priego <efpriego@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi all,
Is it possible to know the membership of this list, or if privacy/consent is an issue at least some anonymised data, re: number of subscribed members, and/or proportion of members who do not currently serve in ADHO/ACH/EDAH/GO::DH committees/boards?
Thanks!
On 19 Oct 2017 21:40, "Roopika Risam" <rrisam@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear Alex,
As an executive member, I say yes to this.
Sincerely,RoopikaSent from my iPhone
--Roopika Risam, PhDAssistant Professor of EnglishChair, Program Area for Content EducationSalem State University
Thank you, Barbara. I wish nothing more than that.
In the spirit of democracy, I ask all current executive members to say they agree for this vote to take place on the membership. A simple majority is all we need. We do not need for the vote to take place in secret—nothing on the bylaws about that. The bylaws, on the other hand do encourage important issues to be polled by members:
"Individual members in good standing have the right to vote in GO::DH elections and such issues as the Executive shall decide to poll the membership on."
Just say aye if you agree.
If the executive approves the passing of the poll, we will stick to our schedule, and vote on December 15. This gives us time to deliberate and secure a proper referendum, with an electoral officer assuring the standards of the proceedings.
a.
On Mon, Oct 16, 2017 at 10:02 PM, B. Bordalejo <barbara.bordalejo@arts.kuleuven.be > wrote:
Dear Alex,
Thank you for putting my name forward. Of course, as always, I am willing to work with Dan and others in making this case. However, I would like to be assured that that the decision will not be only in the hands of the executive, but the whole of the GO::DH membership. After all, this is precisely what you have been proposing, right?
Best,
BB
On 16/10/2017 17:48, Alex Gil wrote:
Thank you all,
Real quick, so I don't interrupt your conversation too much. Dan, would you be amenable to making your argument into a Google Doc? Perhaps Glen and Barbara would like to add. Just so that we can keep organized.
That's all,Please continue. This will be enormously helpful for the executive committee when it comes time to make a decision. As always feel free to write in the language you are comfortable in. We will figure it out.
a.
On Mon, Oct 16, 2017 at 7:17 PM, Amy Earhart <aearhart@tamu.edu> wrote:
Hello all,
It seems a large part of this discussion is not about ADHO, but rather about if we think our goals are best accomplished in an organizational structure. In some ways putting GO::DH into a large organization like ADHO is a poor fit. GO::DH started as a very grass roots organization that resisted hierarchies, committees, officers, etc. and rather used social media and loose collaborations to create some sort of a movement or to create small projects. To me we are much more like a social movement, a political movement, than we are a typical academic organization. I think we are at a moment where we need to figure out if such a beginning should be contained within an organization for positive benefits, reject such organizational structures as antithetical to our goals or to come up with some sort of a hybrid model. Thinking about the issue as less about ADHO and more in this structural way has helped me to consider what might be at stake and where we might go.
Best,
Amy
Amy E. EarhartAssociate Professor of EnglishTexas A&M University
______________________________
From: globaloutlookdh-l <globaloutlookdh-l-bounces@uleth.ca > on behalf of Roopika Risam <rrisam@gmail.com>
Sent: October 16, 2017 4:16
To: globaloutlookdh-l, MailList
Subject: Re: [globaloutlookDH-l] Why we should leave ADHO, go minimal and return to the planet.Ernesto,
I know I'm not Alex but the list belongs to the members, so I would argue that the conversation should happen however the members will it.
Roopika
--Roopika Risam, PhDAssistant Professor of EnglishChair, Program Area for Content EducationSalem State UniversityErnestoThank you for this, Alex.Thank you!
We should have a collective deadline of December 1 for deliberations. In that time, we encourage general and executive members to debate on the list what you would like to see GO::DH become. All of your discussion, comments, will be taken into consideration as the executive votes on a final decision by December 15.Should we have that conversation on this thread (i.e. in reply to your message as I am doing now) or would you prefer to have a different thread or even different threads?
Dr Ernesto Priego
@ernestopriego
https://epriego.wordpress.com/
http://www.comicsgrid.com/
Subscribe to the Comics Grid Newsletter: http://eepurl.com/iOYAj
The information contained in this email is confidential and may be legally privileged. It is intended for the addressee(s) only. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this e-mail.
The contents of this e-mail must not be forwarded, disclosed or copied without the sender's consent. The statements and opinions expressed in this message are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of any related organisations, projects, colleagues or employers.
On 15 October 2017 at 20:50, Alex Gil <colibri.alex@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear all,
As promised, here is the document with the argument for why we should leave ADHO. The first round was written by Dr. Roopika Risam and me, but those in support can add their own rationales and arguments, or comment on ours. Instructions are in the Google Doc.
A second argument will be prepared by those who support the idea of becoming a Constituent Organization of ADHO. I think Dan O'Donnell (Canada), Barbara Bordalejo (Argentina) and Glen Worthey (USA) have signaled they would be interested in drafting such a document. Hopefully sooner, rather than later, so we can proceed with deliberations.
After the second argument is made, a third argument is possible if enough members feel there should be a middle path, or a "third way."
We should have a collective deadline of December 1 for deliberations. In that time, we encourage general and executive members to debate on the list what you would like to see GO::DH become. All of your discussion, comments, will be taken into consideration as the executive votes on a final decision by December 15.
We will announce the results of the process before the year ends, and hopefully move forward with renewed energy into the next stage of GO::DH. Next year, I will pass on the baton to a new chair who will carry out our collective will, but will help in the transition, whatever that is, as long as I'm chair.
All best,Alex.
_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh- You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.l
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go tohttp://listserv.uleth.ca/mai_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
lman/options/globaloutlookdh-l You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.
_________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh- You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.l
_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh-l You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.
_______________________________________________ globaloutlookdh-l mailing list globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailm an/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted. If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh-l You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.
_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh-l You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.
_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh-l You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.
_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh-l You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.
_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/globaloutlookdh-l You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.
Roopika Risam, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of English
_______________________________________________
globaloutlookdh-l mailing list
globaloutlookdh-l@uleth.ca
http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/listinfo/ globaloutlookdh-l
You are currently subscribed to this list in NON-digest mode. This means you receive every message as it is posted.
If this represents too much traffic, you can also subscribe in DIGEST mode. This sends out a single email once a day containing the entire day's postings. To change your settings go to http://listserv.uleth.ca/mailman/options/ You can request a password reminder from this page if you have forgotten yours.globaloutlookdh-l